Select "print" from your browser's "File" menu.

Back to Post
Username Post: Harmonic balancer puller
roadster-rob
Contributor
Posts 195
roadster-rob
05-21-12 11:05 AM - Post#2228219    

I'm looking to check the state of the crankshaft gear etc on my '53 235.

I don't have a puller so guess I will have to make one. What size bolts do I need to use to attach the puller to the crank pulley, these are the two either side of the centre of the pulley.

And is it easy to get replacement chains? Thanks.
2-28s313233
"3rd Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 502
2-28s313233
05-21-12 11:34 AM - Post#2228224    

The threads for the bolts are 3/8-16. It does not have a timing chain. It has a Camshaft gear and crankshaft gear.
Cleon
1928 Chevy touring
1942 Chevy Sport coupe
1949 Chevy Sport coupe
1954 Chevy Bel Air HTP
1970 El Camino
1971 Monte Carlo

roadster-rob
Contributor
Posts 195
roadster-rob
05-21-12 01:49 PM - Post#2228275    

Thanks, I remembered the moment I posted it there is no timing chain.

What generally can fail in this area, or starts wearing out? I did post last week about all of a sudden a sort of rotational metallic sound, crunching, grinding and the sound of something giving up from the lower engine front I would say which I thought was very serious.

I had the sump off and found no problem on the lower end or metal bits in the sump. I have since done some miles on it, and the oil pressur is down - when cold and I fired her up the pressure rocketed to the top for a few minutes, then would slowly makes its way down to midway, and it would stay there. Now, it goes between midway and top pressure from cold and comes down to below midway when warm. It doesn't run quite so well either, a bit of hesitancy/missing almost at higher revs.

I'm unsure what the problem is, i thought I should check behing the timing cover on the front in case something has gone there. The crank pulley is tight. I have to ask, if this just pulls off, how do you get it back on - and retain it in place? Not sure I understand.
BottleJack
Forum Newbie
Posts 42
05-21-12 02:10 PM - Post#2228282    

Stop.
Read.
1---- SHOP MANUAL

2----CONTENTS

3---- Harmonic Balancer Section


roadster-rob
Contributor
Posts 195
roadster-rob
05-21-12 02:13 PM - Post#2228283    

Read it already.

BottleJack
Forum Newbie
Posts 42
05-21-12 02:41 PM - Post#2228293    

Removal? -I've had moderate success with old steering wheel pullers (the odd cross or Y shaped ones)using proper sized bolts and stacks of washers to even out the pulling load.

Then I guess stuff up-front noises could be:
water pump bearings ... fan blade loose or broken rattling ... gear teeth meshing problem in little crankshaft to big cam gear ... cam thrust plate clearances ... #1tappet on cam noise ....etc.

Harmonic Balancer Installation; besides threading the crankshaft to accept a special installer tool ---- trick method is to clean crankshaft shaft real good, make sure keys are in place, gently heat balancer in home oven on low heat, wear gloves, slide it onto cold crankshaft tip (plastic bag of ice around shaft or CO2 fire extinguisher get em' cold).

Good luck in your efforts!

roadster-rob
Contributor
Posts 195
roadster-rob
05-21-12 03:02 PM - Post#2228308    

Thanks for the advice!
usmile4
"6th Year Gold Supporting Member
Posts 3081
05-21-12 04:09 PM - Post#2228335    

Or while you have the balancer off, drill and tap the crank to accept a bolt to mount the balancer when you replace it.
Bill Gommel

49 chevy Styleline (Sold), 51 Styleline 2 dr Special, 235 (from a 61 truck) bored .060 over, Dual Carter/Webers, Fenton Headers, T5- 5 speed with a 56 rear end.

2blu52
"12th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 13078
05-21-12 07:14 PM - Post#2228400    

If it is running and running fairly well I would put timing gear at the bottom of the list. How about water pump, or generator for starts. If a timing gear goes then it is doubtful the car would run and since there is plenty of oil flow from the engine to the gear housing and return there would be metal flakes in the oil if the timing gear was eating itself alive.
"PEACE IS THAT GLORIUS MOMENT IN HISTORY WHEN EVERY ONE STANDS AROUND RELOADING"

THOMAS JEFFERSON

bobg1951chevy
"6th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 4885
bobg1951chevy
05-21-12 10:04 PM - Post#2228474    

Bob G.

1951 Chevy Styleline Deluxe 2 dr sedan. 1955 235 engine. 3 speed trans. Cast Fenton Headers with Smithy mufflers.

www.picturetrail.com/sfx/album/view/215790 56...







roadster-rob
Contributor
Posts 195
roadster-rob
05-22-12 12:37 AM - Post#2228497    

Yeah, it's odd. I didn't find any metal flakes in the pan - nothing. Just frustrating as what I heard sounded very serious.

The water pump is off and turns freely, no sound from it, it spins a little easier than the new one I have to replace it with, but it is old. The fins also look good on the inside.

I am running a 12v alternator, that too is fine.

I don't really want to have to pull the harmonic balancer and check the gears but thought it worthwhile. I agree it is probably not this but I am working my way through items 1 by 1...
brokenhead
Contributor
Posts 162
05-22-12 05:27 AM - Post#2228530    

hope you didn't put the pan back on, the real annoying part is taking the pan off to take the two bolts out of the bottom of the timing gear cover. also there is really nothing up there that would affect oil pressure there is a little spray nozzle that goes to the gears, but that is about it. I would also put this at the bottom of the list. You could purchase a puller, that would be one way to do it. The damper is just held on with friction, and if it is anything like mine, not much friction at that. Also if you tap the end for a bolt, bear in mind as you tighten it up you are trying to pull the end off of the crankshaft, unless the hole goes all the way to the web of the crankshaft. At which point it is pulling it into the crank. Yeah I know I will get lots of comments on this last bit, but think about it a little, and it makes perfect sense, (I never thought about it until I had mine done and the fella brought this up as they were having problems with breaking the snouts off of crankshafts) It probably won't matter on one of these engines, as many people have done it with a shallow hole in the end, but it is something to think about.
roadster-rob
Contributor
Posts 195
roadster-rob
05-22-12 05:32 AM - Post#2228531    

I haven't pulled the pan back off yet so that's ok. I'm waiting for my replacement gaskets.
brokenhead
Contributor
Posts 162
05-22-12 05:36 AM - Post#2228532    

I tapped the two holes for 3/8"-16 and put the bolts in from the front, and twice now it has saved my bacon
Keith_Knox
Moderator and "10th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 2731
Keith_Knox
05-22-12 05:39 AM - Post#2228533    

With the pan off, it is a good time to change out the two bolts for the front cover to studs, that way the front cover can be removed without removing the pan first.
1948 Chevy Fleetmaster Coupe Purchased 6/2010.
1996 Chevy Monte Carlo
2002 Dodge Dakota Quad Cab
2013 F150 Crew Cab

Keith_Knox
Moderator and "10th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 2731
Keith_Knox
05-22-12 05:48 AM - Post#2228538    

When did they use the fibre cam gear? I just looked at the parts book and it shows both.
1948 Chevy Fleetmaster Coupe Purchased 6/2010.
1996 Chevy Monte Carlo
2002 Dodge Dakota Quad Cab
2013 F150 Crew Cab

usmile4
"6th Year Gold Supporting Member
Posts 3081
05-22-12 05:52 AM - Post#2228542    

I also did the tap on the two bolts at the bottom. Just use a good amount of brake clean to wash away all of the little filings.
Bill Gommel

49 chevy Styleline (Sold), 51 Styleline 2 dr Special, 235 (from a 61 truck) bored .060 over, Dual Carter/Webers, Fenton Headers, T5- 5 speed with a 56 rear end.

roadster-rob
Contributor
Posts 195
roadster-rob
05-22-12 05:59 AM - Post#2228547    

I believe you can get aluminium and fibre cam gears. Would aluminium be the better one to go with?
rrausch
"12th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 9707
05-22-12 07:21 AM - Post#2228572    

Yes. The aluminum gear came stock in the 261.
1953 210 Convertible, 261 with dual Carter YF 966S carbs, P.S., Remote Bendix P.B. Booster... shade-tree restoration about done.



BottleJack
Forum Newbie
Posts 42
05-22-12 08:42 AM - Post#2228588    

For 1953, the cam gear Chevrolet listed was a 54 tooth helical(pn- 838436)Bakelite and fiber composition with a steel hub insert.

There has been a Chevrolet Heavy Duty Gear Unit (Crankshaft and Camshaft set w/both gears,thrust bearing, spacing ring, gasket, 2bolts ) used on 1940-53 (pn- 3697087 ---exept:Powerglide)and it is seen on many of the 235 truck versions ... Cam gear is an aluminum alloy with steel hub insert.

I have seen some aftermarket cam gears; Egge Machine has a list (hard to tell if aluminum or fiber) in their TG2500 series.

brokenhead
Contributor
Posts 162
05-22-12 12:01 PM - Post#2228651    

the best I can figure the fiber (quiet) was used in cars and aluminum was used in trucks.
Keith_Knox
Moderator and "10th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 2731
Keith_Knox
05-22-12 09:23 PM - Post#2228824    

That makes sense. Maybe Gene will chime in about the gears.
1948 Chevy Fleetmaster Coupe Purchased 6/2010.
1996 Chevy Monte Carlo
2002 Dodge Dakota Quad Cab
2013 F150 Crew Cab

roadster-rob
Contributor
Posts 195
roadster-rob
05-23-12 11:41 AM - Post#2229003    

I've made up a puller to pull the crank pulley off, see attached photo, I hope it is shown. I've started turning the centre bolt but the pulley just doesn't seem to want to move towards me - am I missing something here? Is there anything else retaining the pulley?


Also, how do you get the pulley back on once off? I don't have any presses or anything...
bobg1951chevy
"6th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 4885
bobg1951chevy
05-23-12 02:52 PM - Post#2229057    

I believe the puller you have made is underpowered, for the job at hand.

Click on this attachment .... look at pages 6-24 and 6-25 for directions regarding the balancer. Look at the puller being used.
http://chevy.oldcarmanualproject.com/shop/1949_53/...

Good luck.
Bob G.

1951 Chevy Styleline Deluxe 2 dr sedan. 1955 235 engine. 3 speed trans. Cast Fenton Headers with Smithy mufflers.

www.picturetrail.com/sfx/album/view/215790 56...







brokenhead
Contributor
Posts 162
05-23-12 02:58 PM - Post#2229059    

there is nothing but magic holding them on. Make sure you arent trying to pull the damper apart, meaning make sure you are pushing on the crank and not part of the damper. Mine I can't quite just yank it off, but I don't need a wrench to turn the tension bolt on the puller.
roadster-rob
Contributor
Posts 195
roadster-rob
05-23-12 03:28 PM - Post#2229069    

Thanks, I do have the manual but not the puller, hence made something. I will make sure I am not trying to pull the damper apart. Will have another go tomorrow - late here in the UK.

brokenhead
Contributor
Posts 162
05-23-12 04:32 PM - Post#2229087    

the standard method of installation is to heat the balancer slightly, cool the crank, and use a hammer and wooden block or something to keep from dinging up the end of the balancer, The aren't really on that tight (at least in my limited experience) I taken off 4 of them and none of them were what I would consider an adequate friction fit. I never had to heat or cool anything, and it was no problem at all. I think mostly the fan belt keeps them from coming off...It seems to me using a real puller to remove would be the way to go, I'm sure they are available over there aren't they? They aren't expensive at all.
usmile4
"6th Year Gold Supporting Member
Posts 3081
05-23-12 06:02 PM - Post#2229106    

When I took the one off my 49 I had to soak the center with penetrating oil as the gunk and rust had fuzed it together quite tightly. Your homemade puller might be flexing too.
Bill Gommel

49 chevy Styleline (Sold), 51 Styleline 2 dr Special, 235 (from a 61 truck) bored .060 over, Dual Carter/Webers, Fenton Headers, T5- 5 speed with a 56 rear end.

BottleJack
Forum Newbie
Posts 42
05-23-12 07:17 PM - Post#2229129    

As mentioned, when stuck, a little spray of penetrating oil may help ....AND if you keep the tension on the H-Balancer with your home-made puller ... maybe try using the VIBRATION of an air tool (or impact wrench) held somewhere on the H-Balancer hub metal. NOT using it to put a socket on/off a nut, but using it strictly to vibrate on the metal housing. That vibrating bluuuuuurpp from an air tool or impact wrench seems to sometimes help get penetrating oil into crevices and thus SHAAAAAAAAKE stuck stuff off of tight shafts . Similarly, a Candy Hammer, or small brass machinist hammer gently tapping at the balancer housing while under puller tension could help. DON'T hammer ....tap....tap.....tap. Be nice to the crankshaft

Be careful if your radiator is still in, use a piece of plywood to protect its' fins.

Cheers!Best of luck in your efforts.
bobg1951chevy
"6th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 4885
bobg1951chevy
05-23-12 09:40 PM - Post#2229171    

Working in a Chevy shop for many years, nothing was heated or cooled to fit..
Bob G.

1951 Chevy Styleline Deluxe 2 dr sedan. 1955 235 engine. 3 speed trans. Cast Fenton Headers with Smithy mufflers.

www.picturetrail.com/sfx/album/view/215790 56...







bobg1951chevy
"6th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 4885
bobg1951chevy
05-23-12 09:41 PM - Post#2229172    

How would you fit a puller and air tool on the balancer if the radiator is still there?
Bob G.

1951 Chevy Styleline Deluxe 2 dr sedan. 1955 235 engine. 3 speed trans. Cast Fenton Headers with Smithy mufflers.

www.picturetrail.com/sfx/album/view/215790 56...







OldDad
Senior Member
Posts 1849
OldDad
05-24-12 09:57 AM - Post#2229287    

  • bobg1951chevy Said:
How would you fit a puller and air tool on the balancer if the radiator is still there?



Probably one of those "Stealth" flatraters.
The S.O.B. from the factory...
71 1/2 ton, 64 Chevelle SS, 57 2dr Hardtop, 57 2dr Sedan, 57 Corvette, 52 2dr Hardtop, 52 2dr Sedan, and now a 49 Plymouth Coupe

BottleJack
Forum Newbie
Posts 42
05-24-12 10:20 AM - Post#2229291    

bobg1951chevy : "How would you fit a puller and air tool on the balancer if the radiator is still there?"

Read my comment. I clearly say nothing about "fitting ...an air tool" on a balancer.
I thought I made it quite clear in my phrase "held somewhere on the H-Balancer hub metal."
Its not any stealth flatrate, it's a trick from marine mechanics who oft need to remove stuck flywheels , u-joints, etc, from severe wet conditions that seized hub to shaft via galvanic reactions.

The OP made no reference to car or truck, radiator in or out, or partially so... or maybe he will be latter in future messing with that balancer with radiator in? Just passing a mild tip to a guy in the UK working on an old Chevy.
roadster-rob
Contributor
Posts 195
roadster-rob
05-24-12 11:01 AM - Post#2229306    

Now, now gents!

The first thing I took out was the radiator! Drained it first of course.

I've put loads of WD40 in, couldn't pull the pulley even with a proper puller, heated it, still no joy. It now appears the puller is slowly pulling away from the pulley, it won't go any tighter, the pulley is spinning. Something's not right. See the second pic. More WD40 I think.




70fierro
Member
Posts 542
70fierro
05-24-12 11:28 AM - Post#2229316    

I tried one of those universal pullers when i had the engine out and had no luck with it. It would flex a bit.

I used a beefier 2 sided puller similar to this one and it did the trick. It took some muscle to get it to break free i remember.

a long prybar through the puller rested on the frame should keep it from spinning. Cesar


eplantage
Senior Member
Posts 1647
eplantage
05-24-12 12:44 PM - Post#2229335    

Did you try popping that center bolt once you had it tight with a BIG FLIPPIN HAMMER? Then tighten the bolt again and repeat hitting it with the BFH.
Reinstall with the BFH and a block of hardwood.
Age: 59 at the moment
1950 Chevrolet Sedan Delivery
1953 BelAir Convertible Project
2002 Heritage Springer FLSTSI

bobg1951chevy
"6th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 4885
bobg1951chevy
05-24-12 02:11 PM - Post#2229364    

  • OldDad Said:
  • bobg1951chevy Said:
How would you fit a puller and air tool on the balancer if the radiator is still there?



Probably one of those "Stealth" flatraters.




Yes, factory man .... you and I have seen them, haven't we ?
Bob G.

1951 Chevy Styleline Deluxe 2 dr sedan. 1955 235 engine. 3 speed trans. Cast Fenton Headers with Smithy mufflers.

www.picturetrail.com/sfx/album/view/215790 56...







bobg1951chevy
"6th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 4885
bobg1951chevy
05-24-12 02:18 PM - Post#2229369    

  • BottleJack Said:
bobg1951chevy : "How would you fit a puller and air tool on the balancer if the radiator is still there?"

Read my comment. I clearly say nothing about "fitting ...an air tool" on a balancer.
I thought I made it quite clear in my phrase "held somewhere on the H-Balancer hub metal."
Its not any stealth flatrate, it's a trick from marine mechanics who oft need to remove stuck flywheels , u-joints, etc, from severe wet conditions that seized hub to shaft via galvanic reactions.

The OP made no reference to car or truck, radiator in or out, or partially so... or maybe he will be latter in future messing with that balancer with radiator in? Just passing a mild tip to a guy in the UK working on an old Chevy.



maybe try using the VIBRATION of an air tool (or impact wrench) held somewhere on the H-Balancer hub metal. NOT using it to put a socket on/off a nut, but using it strictly to vibrate on the metal housing. That vibrating bluuuuuurpp from an air tool or impact wrench seems to sometimes help get penetrating oil into crevices and thus SHAAAAAAAAKE stuck stuff off of tight shafts . Similarly, a Candy Hammer, or small brass machinist hammer gently tapping at the balancer housing while under puller tension could help. DON'T hammer ....tap....tap.....tap. Be nice to the crankshaft

Be careful if your radiator is still in, use a piece of plywood to protect its' fins.

Ohhhhhh, now I see, the air tool will massage the balancer off! Sorry, still need room to get the air tool in place.
Bob G.

1951 Chevy Styleline Deluxe 2 dr sedan. 1955 235 engine. 3 speed trans. Cast Fenton Headers with Smithy mufflers.

www.picturetrail.com/sfx/album/view/215790 56...







2-28s313233
"3rd Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 502
2-28s313233
05-24-12 02:33 PM - Post#2229377    

  • eplantage Said:
Did you try popping that center bolt once you had it tight with a BIG FLIPPIN HAMMER? Then tighten the bolt again and repeat hitting it with the BFH.
Reinstall with the BFH and a block of hardwood.


I just removed one from a 1931 engine last week and that is the only way I got it to break loose.
You do have to keep the engine from turning.
1928 Chevy touring
1942 Chevy Sport coupe
1949 Chevy Sport coupe
1954 Chevy Bel Air HTP
1970 El Camino
1971 Monte Carlo

BottleJack
Forum Newbie
Posts 42
05-24-12 02:48 PM - Post#2229382    

bobg1951chevy : If you don't like what I type, don't read it.
I was just trying help a UK guy out on who seems to have a sticky problem.
Save your belligerent attitude and personnel attacks and back off. Go play bully games on the H.A.M.B.
I am not impressed.

I started here on CT in 2002 and it was guys who prefer to pump a bloated ego instead of helping a guys out who made me stay away so long.

Finally, I do sincerely apologize to those other good folks who have to see this cr*p bickering.

Time for me to take another vacation. How's the weather in the UK ??...
roadster-rob
Contributor
Posts 195
roadster-rob
05-24-12 03:06 PM - Post#2229387    

Thanks for everyone's thoughts. Will keep having a go at it and will let you know when I manage to get this sucker off so I can see inside the timing cover.

The weather in the UK has been poor until this week. It is hot and sunny here now, and about time. I should be in the garden with an ice cold beer, instead I'm slaving under a carport which is like an oven. That beer will be quaffed in no time when the pulley comes off!
bobg1951chevy
"6th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 4885
bobg1951chevy
05-24-12 03:07 PM - Post#2229390    

"Save your belligerent attitude and personnel attacks and back off. Go play bully games on the H.A.M.B.
I am not impressed."

Certainly, I am not impressed with you, either. YOU write so many words, but say so little.

Let's agree to disagree. Have a nice vacation.

Bob G.

1951 Chevy Styleline Deluxe 2 dr sedan. 1955 235 engine. 3 speed trans. Cast Fenton Headers with Smithy mufflers.

www.picturetrail.com/sfx/album/view/215790 56...







VANDENPLAS
Frequent Contributor
Posts 1458
VANDENPLAS
05-24-12 07:23 PM - Post#2229465    

I have used the vibration thing alot over the years to get h-balancers off.

what i do is with an air hammer and a long enough snub nose chisel to get between the balancer and the rad and "burp" it repeatedly all the way around as close to the center as possible, this usually removes even the most stubborn balancers.

also with the pullet you have on the balancer tightened up try smacking the center bolt with a big f'ing hammer,this will "shock" the balancer off.

yes us "stealth flatraters" will find any and all means to an end to beat "book time"


and as far as tapping the crank for a bolt what i have read is to use a crank bolt from a small block.its a really small bolt and to me it wont really pull the balancer in or hold it with and real torque,its more for added security and assurance that the pulley wont walk off.

i have taken a bunch of these pulley off and most come off quite easily with just a little torque a bolt grip puller,but i had one that just would not come off,so between tons of good penetration oil and all the tips i laid out above it came off.

with you being in the UK try getting your hands on some WURTH "ROST OFF" OR "ROST OFF ICE" the 2 best penetrating oils out there is you ask me.
Every mother on Earth gave birth to a child.Except my mother,she gave birth to a legend .

ALWAYS TRUST PEOPLE WHO LIKE BIG BUTTS,THEY CANNOT LIE.

Panama Red
"3rd Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 481
Panama Red
05-24-12 07:45 PM - Post#2229467    

I get a little concerned when folks suggest "smacking with a hammer" any part of the crankshaft assembly. Have you ever seen what that does to the thrust surface of the main bearing which has the thrust flange? I know guys who used a hammer to install a balancer on a SBC in the "old" days and ended up with major crankshaft end play. Personally, I prefer to use a puller for removal and the proper bolt type installation tool. I had a stuck balancer on one of my 235's and I had to use 5/16 bolts with nuts and washers on the back side as the threads in the balancer would not hold the pressure.
Jon Hansen

My '41 Chevy blog

Blog #2

bobg1951chevy
"6th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 4885
bobg1951chevy
05-24-12 10:46 PM - Post#2229525    

"yes us "stealth flatraters" will find any and all means to an end to beat "book time"

Yes, how well I know. And isn't that the one BIG problem with the flat rate system? Going into a $500.00 repair job ..... but beating book time causes another several hundred dollars in damage in additional parts, etc.
Bob G.

1951 Chevy Styleline Deluxe 2 dr sedan. 1955 235 engine. 3 speed trans. Cast Fenton Headers with Smithy mufflers.

www.picturetrail.com/sfx/album/view/215790 56...







brokenhead
Contributor
Posts 162
05-25-12 02:49 AM - Post#2229542    

the biggest problem with using an installation tool is the fact the end of the crank isn't threaded and thus there is no where to install said installation tool. Just one tiny little detail that will hang you up. Also they aren't really that tight, maybe stuck coming off, but going back on after everything has been cleaned up should be easy. I have only done this 4 times so my experience is limited. But I have read many accounts of this issue and have heard of no problems. (this topic is as common as bypass filters, and 216/235 swaps) there is several comments alluding to this in this very thread. You wouldn't technically use the threads in the crank to pull the damper on, you thread the installation tool fully into the crank, then use the threads on the tool to pull the damper on, so as not to incrementally and methodically destroy the threads in the end of the crank. Also please refer to my earlier post of how a shallow hole in the end will tend to want to pull the end off of the crankshaft, all the while keeping in mind you probably aren't (at least you shouldn't be) tightening that bolt so tight as to be any concern. But is something to think about. You know the getting all the data together so as to be able to make an informed decision and all that.
VANDENPLAS
Frequent Contributor
Posts 1458
VANDENPLAS
05-25-12 02:55 AM - Post#2229543    

  • bobg1951chevy Said:
"yes us "stealth flatraters" will find any and all means to an end to beat "book time"

Yes, how well I know. And isn't that the one BIG problem with the flat rate system? Going into a $500.00 repair job ..... but beating book time causes another several hundred dollars in damage in additional parts, etc.




i disagree bob.

there is a difference between being a hack and butchering a job and finding an alternate means to getting a job done.just because the shop manual wants a part removed in a certain way does not make it the correct way,some times "outside the box thinking" is required to get the job done.

i dont butcher or do crappy work just to "beat time" but i can think on my own and dont need to follow the book step by step.

i have had alot of apprentices try and be fats at doing a particular job or another with disastrous results! i always tell them,get good at the job and speed will come naturally.



and yet flat rate system is flawed. it creates a thought process in some mechanics that the only way to make money is to "rape and pillage" "throwing parts at a problem" instead of actually diagnosing the issue is another as getting diag time in most dealerships is like pulling teeth. or "campaigning" known warranty issues that pay well.

in Quebec the flatrate system is illegal,so you get you hourly wage (40-44 h) per week plus a "productivity bonus" for any hours earned above that" i think this is a fair way to pay a tech as then when you get stuck with an electrical nightmare the time will be spent to fix it correctly and it will make the "dog f'ers" want to move a bit faster to get the dangling carrot.



what was said in another thread about bunny trails? seems that is happening here!
Every mother on Earth gave birth to a child.Except my mother,she gave birth to a legend .

ALWAYS TRUST PEOPLE WHO LIKE BIG BUTTS,THEY CANNOT LIE.

brokenhead
Contributor
Posts 162
05-25-12 03:15 AM - Post#2229545    

bunnies are cute
gjwach
Forum Newbie
Posts 73
05-25-12 06:07 AM - Post#2229598    

Yes bunnies are indeed cute however the shots that seem to be taken at one another as threads get longer are not.

We are all on this forum to get help or provide help and in most cases do both. Everybody vhas different experiences and have tried or used different ways to resolve difficult problems with the tools and expertise we have at hand. Doing so, working from others experiences gives each of us the opportunity to reslove a problem much more quickly than may have otherwise doing it in a trial and error method.

However today alone two threads have gone on for long periods with many postings and the result was sniping and taking shots at one another instead of being productive.

I just don't understand nor see the point that we need to put others down in our old car rebuilding family in order to share our ideas on how something can be done.

I know I just painted a target on my back for the sniping however I am a big boy and can take it however after seeing to posts degrade into negative comments within thew same 24 hour period I needed to clear my throat.

Greg: 54 Red & White (well will be someday) Hardtop being done as original (except 12 volt and disc brakes) and loaded with options (i.e. original pwr steering, pwr seats, autronic eye, sunvisor, spot light, acc lighting and a continental kit)

OldDad
Senior Member
Posts 1849
OldDad
05-25-12 09:46 AM - Post#2229667    

Sounds like some of us grew up in a time without Political correctness, when you could poke good fun at a fellow and give him a bad time while all the time knowing that he would get back at you. Made the work day fun. Now it seems the younger generation is more concerned about their feelings. Well at my age I frankly don't give a s--- about Political correctness and will continue to have fun with my fellow members and "Stealth Flatraters" as long as I can still turn a wrench. I hope they find me face down on the shop floor with a wrench in my hand, cause when the flip me over I'll be smiling!
Everyone have a great and fun day!
The S.O.B. from the factory...
71 1/2 ton, 64 Chevelle SS, 57 2dr Hardtop, 57 2dr Sedan, 57 Corvette, 52 2dr Hardtop, 52 2dr Sedan, and now a 49 Plymouth Coupe

VANDENPLAS
Frequent Contributor
Posts 1458
VANDENPLAS
05-25-12 09:48 AM - Post#2229669    

Hey G very well said

That is why I spend my time here and not on the HAMB as this place is like a big family with mom and dad in the next room listening.

We have the freedom to say what we want wit knowing that if we say the wrong thing we are going to get belittled or put down.

I say let's keep it that way asbits far too easy for us all to better then each other and stay on our soapboxes
Every mother on Earth gave birth to a child.Except my mother,she gave birth to a legend .

ALWAYS TRUST PEOPLE WHO LIKE BIG BUTTS,THEY CANNOT LIE.

bobg1951chevy
"6th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 4885
bobg1951chevy
05-25-12 01:01 PM - Post#2229709    

I agree with your post, but trust me, over the years, too much damage was done by FR Techs, at the expense of the dealer, the customer and the factory.

Flat Rate should be done away with, open a new topic, if you want to get into this deeper.
Bob G.

1951 Chevy Styleline Deluxe 2 dr sedan. 1955 235 engine. 3 speed trans. Cast Fenton Headers with Smithy mufflers.

www.picturetrail.com/sfx/album/view/215790 56...







bobg1951chevy
"6th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 4885
bobg1951chevy
05-25-12 01:09 PM - Post#2229712    

  • OldDad Said:
Sounds like some of us grew up in a time without Political correctness, when you could poke good fun at a fellow and give him a bad time while all the time knowing that he would get back at you. Made the work day fun. Now it seems the younger generation is more concerned about their feelings. Well at my age I frankly don't give a s--- about Political correctness and will continue to have fun with my fellow members and "Stealth Flatraters" as long as I can still turn a wrench. I hope they find me face down on the shop floor with a wrench in my hand, cause when the flip me over I'll be smiling!
Everyone have a great and fun day!




I understand your comments, I agree with your comments, I believe as you do ... I DO NOT believe or support or give a s*** about political correctness.

AMEN.
Bob G.

1951 Chevy Styleline Deluxe 2 dr sedan. 1955 235 engine. 3 speed trans. Cast Fenton Headers with Smithy mufflers.

www.picturetrail.com/sfx/album/view/215790 56...







gjwach
Forum Newbie
Posts 73
05-25-12 01:36 PM - Post#2229721    

Well as I expected the barage begins.

At almost 50 i know I was around and old enough to remember the time before political correctness was mandadted by the government. However I also seen to remember that respect and common courtesy although not mandated seemed to be the norm as well.

My momma always told me if you have nothing nice to say you should say nothing at all and I am also quite certain she got that from her momma and so on back through the generations.

I will follow my momma's teaching and shut up now.

You may now return to your regularly scheduled verbal beatings.

and have a nice day.
Greg: 54 Red & White (well will be someday) Hardtop being done as original (except 12 volt and disc brakes) and loaded with options (i.e. original pwr steering, pwr seats, autronic eye, sunvisor, spot light, acc lighting and a continental kit)

bobg1951chevy
"6th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 4885
bobg1951chevy
05-25-12 01:47 PM - Post#2229723    

  • BottleJack Said:
bobg1951chevy : If you don't like what I type, don't read it.
I was just trying help a UK guy out on who seems to have a sticky problem.
Save your belligerent attitude and personnel attacks and back off. Go play bully games on the H.A.M.B.
I am not impressed.

I started here on CT in 2002 and it was guys who prefer to pump a bloated ego instead of helping a guys out who made me stay away so long.

Finally, I do sincerely apologize to those other good folks who have to see this cr*p bickering.

Time for me to take another vacation. How's the weather in the UK ??...



I will, in all honesty, apologize for not reading/understanding your initial post correctly .... thought you were installing a puller, then the air gun .... all with the radiator still in place.

Regarding the "vibration" technique, it was commonly done with an air chisel type gun, but the down side can be parts with stress cracks.
Bob G.

1951 Chevy Styleline Deluxe 2 dr sedan. 1955 235 engine. 3 speed trans. Cast Fenton Headers with Smithy mufflers.

www.picturetrail.com/sfx/album/view/215790 56...







chum58
"2nd Year" Gold Supporting Member
Posts 257
chum58
05-25-12 07:11 PM - Post#2229808    

AMEN

Norm
53 Chev Belair HT
62 261
54 pg/diff
Fenton alum twin with Carter/Webbers
(Tom Langdons)
Corvette split exh. manifold. Cherry Bombs /28in
Petronic ignition

bobg1951chevy
"6th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 4885
bobg1951chevy
05-25-12 08:53 PM - Post#2229845    

Why are you replying to me ??????? Reply to the person who addressed you!
Bob G.

1951 Chevy Styleline Deluxe 2 dr sedan. 1955 235 engine. 3 speed trans. Cast Fenton Headers with Smithy mufflers.

www.picturetrail.com/sfx/album/view/215790 56...







brokenhead
Contributor
Posts 162
05-26-12 05:32 AM - Post#2229918    

just how do you reply to any particlar person? I just know to hit reply and whoever comes up wins. It certainly isn't an intuitive function.
usmile4
"6th Year Gold Supporting Member
Posts 3081
05-26-12 05:51 AM - Post#2229926    

When you want to address a particular person, go that that persons post and use the replay button on that post, then it will replay to that person.
Bill Gommel

49 chevy Styleline (Sold), 51 Styleline 2 dr Special, 235 (from a 61 truck) bored .060 over, Dual Carter/Webers, Fenton Headers, T5- 5 speed with a 56 rear end.

brokenhead
Contributor
Posts 162
05-26-12 09:55 AM - Post#2230008    

makes sense,thanks

NWMO 52 Chevy
Contributor
Posts 577
NWMO  52 Chevy
05-26-12 12:03 PM - Post#2230047    

  • usmile4 Said:
When you want to address a particular person, go that that persons post and use the replay button on that post, then it will replay to that person.



Next to the REPLY button is the quote button which makes it even clearer. Of course, REPLAYing sounds more fun than REPLYing.

Chris

roadster-rob
Contributor
Posts 195
roadster-rob
05-28-12 09:57 AM - Post#2230746    

Ok, progress report. I didn't get anything done over the weekend apart from adding more and more penetrating oil. This is because I was drinking too much beer in the sun. I was just about capable of opening another bottle, but no way capable of turning a wrench

Anyway, I took today off, and got the crank pulley off. Just the oil that did it I reckon. Harmonic balancer is undamaged. Then eventually got the timing gear cover off, that had some very stubborn screws. But relief when it came off - all ok. See picture.



The sump was off obviously and the "dust shield" mentioned in a couple of earlier replies is in place, see picture below.



Everything else looks fine. Working further back, I removed the clutch/flywheel cover and everything looked fine. I then moved behind the transmission to pull the universl joint cover off the front of the driveshaft as I have noticed some clutch judder in first and reverse since this thing happened.

Here is the problem I think. When I installed a new clutch a couple of years ago I noticed one of the cap screws that holds one of the trunnion bearings in place was not tight, so i tightened it up.

See the picture below, I have lost one of them -



I found the washer, but the cap screw is toast and apart from a couple of small metal filings, couldn't find it. I guess it must have made it's way into the transmission?? I think this means transmission out to try and find any bits. I have drained the transmission obviously but did not notice any bits come out.

I need to know a couple of things - the type/size of cap screw so I can get a replacement. Also, in the manual it mentions lock plates to keep these cap screws in place, I presume similar to the lock plate which helps retain the two lower bolts on the steering idler arm assembly. Does anyone hadve a picture of these? I think I will have to fabricate something.

I have driven a couple of hundred miles since this happened with no problems though. Is it going to be a pain to try and locate what is left of the cap screw in the transmission?
bobg1951chevy
"6th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 4885
bobg1951chevy
05-28-12 01:37 PM - Post#2230811    

Here is a pic regarding the lock plate.

After clicking here, scroll down to the bottom right illutration. If you continue to post on the joint, etc, best to start new topic.

http://chevy.oldcarmanualproject.com/1929_54chevyp...

Bob G.

1951 Chevy Styleline Deluxe 2 dr sedan. 1955 235 engine. 3 speed trans. Cast Fenton Headers with Smithy mufflers.

www.picturetrail.com/sfx/album/view/215790 56...







roadster-rob
Contributor
Posts 195
roadster-rob
05-28-12 02:08 PM - Post#2230817    

Thanks for that Bob, I thought that's what it would look like. No problem to fabricate those.

Gearbox to come out now, hopefully tomorrow night my time.
1nice52
"2nd Year" Gold Supporting Member
Posts 273
1nice52
05-28-12 02:47 PM - Post#2230821    

I know you are in the UK and shipping is going to be an issue.
http://www.chevsofthe40s.com/detail/11196/Chevrole ...
RON

"52" Styleline Deluxe (In the family since new)
"53" Bel Air (Bucket list in progress)

roadster-rob
Contributor
Posts 195
roadster-rob
05-28-12 03:10 PM - Post#2230829    

Thanks Ron, good of you.
bobg1951chevy
"6th Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 4885
bobg1951chevy
05-28-12 09:20 PM - Post#2230957    

  • roadster-rob Said:
Thanks for that Bob, I thought that's what it would look like. No problem to fabricate those.

Gearbox to come out now, hopefully tomorrow night my time.



You're welcome
Bob G.

1951 Chevy Styleline Deluxe 2 dr sedan. 1955 235 engine. 3 speed trans. Cast Fenton Headers with Smithy mufflers.

www.picturetrail.com/sfx/album/view/215790 56...







dpurdy
"2nd Year" Silver Supporting Member
Posts 118
dpurdy
05-29-12 08:56 AM - Post#2231085    

You could drill and safety wire the bolts.
Dave

'52 Chev Deluxe Sport Coupe
'69 MGB Tourer
'69 Jaguar E-Type Coupe
'94 Chev K1500 daily driver

roadster-rob
Contributor
Posts 195
roadster-rob
05-30-12 12:36 PM - Post#2231513    

Just added a new post - I found the chewed up bolt. There are some pictures on the new post.
socalpop
Member
Posts 132
socalpop
05-30-12 08:31 PM - Post#2231676    

I used to play the Harmonica Balancer in a band called the "StoveBolts".
http://www.4shared.com/account/dir/iKUzq3SY/ _onlin...

roadster-rob
Contributor
Posts 195
roadster-rob
05-30-12 10:22 PM - Post#2231705    

Ha ha, brilliant. I tried but the beer made me lose my balance...
FusionBB
FusionBB™ Version 2.1
©2003-2006 InteractivePHP, Inc.
Execution time: 0.071 seconds.   Total Queries: 11   Zlib Compression is on.
All times are (GMT -0800) Pacific. Current time is 12:47 AM
Top